Main Page
return to title page

Introduction
The Momentum of Byronism
Terms of engagement

Turgenev: biography
Early upbringing
Early influences
Developing lifestyle
Exile, repatriation, death

Turgenev and political turbulence
Slavophiles and Westernizers
Forces of negation

Byronic influence through others
Pushkin and Lermontov
Anarchists and early nihilists

Fathers and Sons: from the source
Bazarov as nihilist?
Bazarov as Romantic hero?

Conclusion
Bazarov as Byronic negator and idealist
Bibliography

Text-Only Version

Tracing Byron's Influence on the Creation and Development of the Nihilist Bazarov in Ivan Turgenev's Fathers and Sons

INTRODUCTION

Terms of Engagement

To discuss Bazarov in terms of his Byronic traits and ancestry, several terms should be defined. The phenomenon of "Byronism" alone deserves an entire monograph study. It is not my intention to definitively establish a definitive conception of "Byronism;" rather, it is to identify traces of European and Russian Byronic imitations and influences on Turgenev as author and creator of Bazarov. To avoid encountering serious debate on the specific characteristics of Byronism as a literary movement, "Byronism" as understood in this essay can be characterized by the personal and public lifestyle of the poet and by the darkly heroic characters he created which were modeled on his own philosophical conception of himself and his place in the world.

Russian Romanticism will be considered a later extension or continuation of a particularly Byronic brand of European Romanticism that, in its later incarnations, focused upon the perceived demonic and oriental nature of Byron and his characters, often applied to the contemporary political and social situation in Russia. Though various specific dates have been applied to this intellectual period, this essay will combine and conflate the dating used by D. S. Mirsky and by Charles A. Moser to between 1820 and 1841. Most often Russian Romantic authors expressed their philosophies in poetry-often in imitations and loose interpretations of Byron's oriental tales-but frequently chose also to express their ideals in their manner of living.

Nihilism requires at least a working definition; while a more detailed listing of several characteristics of nihilism will be developed later in the paper, a general conception of the term will be a movement of which Bazarov was the first literary example, the creation of whom became a critical defining moment in Russian revolutionary history. Bazarov's emergence created a dual conception of nihilism-a philosophical stance of negation with various precedents, including Byron himself; and a movement of revolutionary reform, involving a group of individuals practicing nihilism's philosophical principle of negation.

The structure of this paper follows the train of thought by which its ideas emerged. Upon studying Byron's earlier work, particularly an oriental tale like "The Giaour," Byron's personal letters, and "English Bards and Scotch Reviewers," I noticed distinct correlation between Byron's dark, biting, incriminating criticism of societal cant and the nihilism of Turgenev's Bazarov in Fathers and Sons. I followed up on this possibility by searching for a direct correlation between the concepts of Byronism and those of Russian nihilism, a search that proved relatively unsuccessful because of the connection of Byronism to Romanticism and nihilism to realism, two literary movements often diametrically opposed to one another. In this study I traced Turgenev's influences in creating the literary nihilist Bazarov and found the connection that I had sought in Turgenev's inspirational roots in Byron, European Byronism, and Russian Romanticism.

return to top of page



* F O O T N O T E S *

1

. . . political and social situation in Russia . . .
See D. S. Mirsky, A History of Russian Literature for an insiders approach to Russian Romanticism; see Charles A. Moser, The Cambridge History of Russian Literature for an outsiders approach. Each contributes a unique perspective to the particular place of literary development within Russian political and socio-economic history.

( r e t u r n )

2

. . . between 1820 and 1841 . . .
Mirsky approaches Russian romanticism as a flowering of "The Golden Age of Poetry" in Russian literary history. He dates "The Golden Age" from 1808 with the emergence of Russian poetry from "the placid insipidities of the school of Dmitriev" when it "acquire[d] an independent and original accent in the first mature work of Zhukovsky" to 1837, the death of Pushkin (72). Within "The Golden Age" he refers to romanticism as a movement that "was in open revolt against the rules of French classicism" (71) beginning in 1820 and extending to the end of the Golden Age. Moser tries to avoid specific dating of the movement, but capitulates with emergence from sentimentalism around 1815 and displacement by realism in the early 1840sgenerally associated with Lermontovs death in 1841 (138).

( r e t u r n )

3

. . . their manner of living . . .
Take Alexander Pushkin and Mikhail Lermontov as prime examples. Both went through a phase of living like Byron and both died prematurely, perhaps attempting to escape Byronic "ennui" in possibly self-inflicted deaths by dueling. Turgenev himself said of Lermontov that he seemed to live a perpetual death wish in an attempt to escape his "profoundly bored" condition; "[Lermontov] felt stifled in the narrow bounds to which he had been confined by destiny" (Levrin, Janko. "Some Notes on Lermontovs Romanticism." Slavonic and East European Review 36 (1958): 69-81. 79.)

( r e t u r n )

4

. . . diametrically opposed to one another . . .
In fact, several critics willingly discuss the Romanticism of anti-nihilism, notably Geoffrey Clive in "Romanticism and Anti-Romanticism in the Nihilism of Bazarov" and Charles A. Moser in Antinihilism in the Russian Novel of the 1860s. As Mosers title suggests, he presents Fathers and Sons as an anti-nihilistic novel, despite Turgenevs insistence, in a letter to K. K. Sluchevsky (April 14/26, 1862), that Bazarov was a nihilist revolutionary: ". . . if he is called a nihilist that word must be read as revolutionary " (Lowe 1983, 211).

( r e t u r n )